Overview
The MoEFCC has filed an affidavit in the Supreme Court stating that it has no objection to the composition of the proposed 10‑member high‑powered expert committee. The committee, to be constituted by the CEC, will draft a uniform definition for the Aravalli hills.
Key Developments
- MoEFCC affirmed the names suggested by the CEC, which include senior officials from FSI, Geological Survey of India, Survey of India, and eminent academicians.
- The affidavit noted that the ministry has no additional names to propose at this stage.
- The Supreme Court, on 26 February, asked the ministry and other stakeholders to recommend domain experts for the panel, emphasizing that only lawful mining would be permitted in the Aravalli region.
- Earlier, on 29 December, the Court stayed its own November 20 order that had accepted a uniform definition and had halted all mining activities pending clarification of critical ambiguities such as the 100‑metre elevation criterion and the 500‑metre inter‑hill gap.
Important Facts
The ten‑member panel is expected to comprise:
- Devi, 1991 IFS officer (Madhya Pradesh cadre) with three decades of experience in forestry education, wildlife policy and institutional leadership.
- Subhash Ashutosh, former Director General of FSI.
- Rajendra Kumar Sharma, former Director of Geological Survey of India.
- Tejal Kanitkar, climate and energy policy expert.
- Jaya Parkash Yadav, senior life‑sciences researcher.
- Tejbir Singh Rana, senior geographer.
- SV Singh, former Additional Surveyor General of India.
- CN Pandey, former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Gujarat.
- Dharmendra Prakash, former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests, Nagaland.
- Additional recommendations: RN Mishra (author) and Vijay Dhasmana (ecological restoration practitioner).
Exam Relevance
Understanding the procedural interface between the judiciary, the executive (MoEFCC), and expert committees is crucial for GS 2 (Polity) and GS 3 (Environment). The case illustrates how legal definitions can affect mining permissions, biodiversity conservation, and sustainable development—core topics in the environment and governance syllabus.
Way Forward
The expert committee must conduct a comprehensive, stakeholder‑inclusive study to resolve ambiguities around the 100‑metre elevation and 500‑metre gap criteria. Its final report will guide the Supreme Court’s next order on permissible mining, thereby shaping the regulatory framework for the Aravalli ecosystem.